QuickTime’s Death means it’s time to Switch!

Well, shortly after support was discontinued for QuickTime 7 for Windows, the United States Computer Emergency Readiness Team (yes, this really exists) or US-CERT, as it’s also known, announced that the Zero Day Initiative has issued advisories for two (1, 2) vulnerabilities found in QuickTime for Windows, basically stating that any Windows machine running QT7 is vulnerable for a cyber attack.  So, as users ran screaming to their computers to uninstall QT7, Adobe and Avid announced that they were working on updates to support a “QuickTime-less” version of their editing and compositing applications, as codecs like ProRes are still dependent on QT being installed on the system attempting to decode them.  Well, around the end of May, Adobe had announced that they have received “certification of our new native technology for our Creative Cloud applications”.  Basically they had updated Premiere Pro internally to remove the need for QuickTime/QT Pro to be running on systems utilizing the Creative Cloud.  Premiere Pro would support codecs like ProRes natively.  Now, keep in mind that Adobe had also stated that “we do anticipate that some older, less used legacy formats may not be directly supported and therefore no longer be accessible. Users may need to find a method of transcoding their legacy media.”  Which, in the grand scheme of things is not that big a deal, as there are many situations these days, where we find ourselves transcoding files to have them work better in our NLE.  Also, Adobe had stated that we are planning on adding native export support to .mov wrapped files of DNxHD and DNxHR. This shows our commitment to the DNxHD/DNxHR codecs. This support augments our currently supported import of DNxHD and DNxHR in .mov and .mxf and native export in .mxf. Similarly, in an effort to allow as many legacy files to be supported as possible we will also be supporting the reading of AAC Audio and PNG Compressed frames and the reading/writing of Animation frames”.  Now, as of the publishing of  this article, if you have updated to the new Premiere Pro CC 2015.3 update (June 2016 update), you can uninstall QuickTime Pro, and Premiere will work natively with your ProRes media.  If you’re still on a legacy version, like many editors currently are, you need to keep QT on your system. In the Premiere Pro CC 2015.3 release notes on the Adobe Blogs website you will see  “Additional native format support: Apple ProRes QuickTime files can be decoded on Windows without needing QuickTime installed on the system. RED camera raw file decoding now supports RED Scarlet-W, Raven, and Weapon cameras, including 8K .r3d footage.  Avid’s official statement on this is that they “have been working on a solution to remove Media Composer’s and Pro Tools’ dependencies on Apple QuickTime libraries. We will be releasing an update later this year to accomplish this. This update will include support for:

  • DNxHR and DNxHD  
  • ProRes
  • H.264
  • TIFF
  • JPEG
  • MP3
  • AAC
  • Uncompressed audio formats (PCM, ADPCM, etc.)”

Now, with that being said, it’s great that we can finally remove QuickTime from our systems, and work with codecs like ProRes natively, but what about outside of our applications.  What do we do in situations where we need to QC a ProRes file to check it when we export it to send to a client, or check the Closed Captioning on a file, or check the LKFS Loudness?  That’s where Telestream Switch comes into play.

Now, one thing that a lot of people will say is that they use VLC because it’s free, and it does a good enough job.  Well, I’ll be honest.  I hate VLC.  Many people love it, and rely on it for their file QC, but it’s not very good.  I don’t even find the way it shrinks and zooms into footage to be very good, and that’s just some basic stuff.   It’s also just that.  A file viewer.  Believe it or not, Switch already up to version three, and Telestream has done something very smart, by releasing three flavors of Switch, depending on your needs.

WHAT’S NEW IN VERSION 3

There are some very clever new features in version three that make it a must upgrade if you’re working with version two.

Compare Alternate Media (Pro)

This one caught me a little off guard, as it’s an awesome idea that you normally would only associate with a feature in a non-linear editing application, but it’s something super smart.  For anyone that is having an issue with a “Before and After” file, meaning that you have a file that you’ve altered in some way, and you need to compare it to what it looked like before, say maybe there is a gamma shift, or something like that.

External Preview to BlackMagic Design interfaces (Pro)

Do you have the new Avid DNxIO, or how about the Intensity Pro 4K?  You can send video directly from Switch to a broadcast monitor via SDI or HDMI so you and/or your clients can view their files for approval, or just as a final once over before delivery.  Keep in mind that the ability to view your files via AJA devices is already a feature of Switch!

More Publishing Options & More Containers (Plus/Pro)

Once you’ve QC’d your files in Switch, you can not only export the files to different file types and codecs, but now in version 3, you also have the ability to upload directly to YouTube, Facebook and Vimeo, right from within the interface.  You also now have more export containers to choose from, like MXF-OP1A.

Publishing

One thing that will confuse a lot of people is what you get in the different versions of Switch, so let’s break it down, and see why, if you do a lot of quality control, file conversion or uploading to social media, Switch 3 Pro will be right for you.

Switch Player – Free!

The most basic flavor that Switch comes in, and is really designed to be a replacement for QuickTime 7 player.  It’s free, and it lets you:

PLAY IT

  • Supports Multi Format playback including MOV, MP4, MXF, GXF,  MPEG Program Streams & Transport Streams, and more.
  • Basic clip navigation including Step, skip or jump forward/reverse, slow motion navigation including  JKL navigation, as well as being able to jump to a specific timecode, frame or time.
  • Support for HEVC, AC3 and WMV Playback on the Mac, but Flip For Mac is required

CHECK IT

Get information from your files, much like using MediaInfo for either Mac or Window, all from within the interface, much like with QuickTime Pro.  Information such as:

  • File properties: size, type, duration, metadata
  • Video properties: format, bit rate, subsampling, color space, aspect ratio, Clean Aperture, and more
  • Audio properties: audio channels, speaker labels, format, sample rate

FIX IT

There is only one “Fix It” feature in the free version of Switch, and that is the ability to do a “Pass Through” export, but you’re limited to 30 seconds, or half the duration of your clip.

Keep in mind that as great as the free player is, there are some limitations to it including:

  • There is a watermark on playback of DNxHD, JPEG2000, HEVC, DNxHR and AC3
  • There is no support for embedded caption playback or WMV playback
  • Limited advanced inspection of application-specific metadata (e.g., AS-11 with DPP metadata)
  • No audio meters, Timeline, compare Alternate Media, or SDI out to external monitors
  • Pass through export limited to 15 seconds or half the duration of the file
  • Export and published videos are watermarked

With that being said, there’s absolutely no reason why you shouldn’t have the free version of Switch on your system, as it’s free, and a fantastic player.  Now, Switch Plus adds additional functionality to each category.  You get all the previous features plus…..

Switch Plus- $49

The second rung up the ladder is $50, and if you’re looking for a basic “QuickTime” type player that takes it up a slight notch, this one would be right for you.  Remember, with what I’m listing below, you get all the features of the free version, plus:

PLAY IT

  • Native playback of Windows Media Files on the Mac.  Flip 4 Mac is not required.
  • The ability to playback and view both Closed Captions and Subtitles files in many different formats including CEA 608/708, SCC, DVB and TTML for captions, and WebVTT, SRT, STL for subtitle files.

Closed Captions

CHECK IT

  • Audio meters that will display true-peaks and momentary loudness values.  This is a huge feature, and worth the $49 upgrade cost right here.

FIX IT

  • Exporting.  That’s right, export files directly from Switch to many popular containers including MOV, MPEG-2 TS/PS, MPEG-4 and MXF (OP-1a, OP-Atom), with Apple ProRes, MPEG-2 Video and x264 codecs.  Now, as far as ProRes goes, please keep in mind that for Mac users, it’s a ProRes codec as per usual.  For Windows users, it’s ProRes HQ 4:2:2 for iTunes only .
  • Publish to Vimeo, YouTube and Facebook.

For anyone who doesn’t do any large quality control jobs, and is just looking for a solid player that can upload files to their favorite social media platforms, Switch Plus is the one for you

Where I work, we do a ton of file QC.  We get files for broadcast and theater, and in just about every codec and frame rate you can imagine.  For us, the Pro version is the way to go, and if you do a lot of file delivery, the Pro version is the one you should consider

Switch Pro- $295

PLAY IT

  • You can playback JPEG2000, DNxHD and DNxHR whether you have Media Composer or the Avid Codecs installed on your system or not.  I should also point out that these codecs play back in the Free version of Switch, but there’s a large watermark placed over the image.

CHECK IT

  • Need to check the Loudness of your spot or production?  Now you can do it right from within Switch Pro via the Loudness monitoring panel which will display the average momentary loudness, average short-term loudness, integrated loudness and loudness range.
  • Preview to external monitors via Blackmagic Design or AJA devices.
  • Compare Alternate Media by loading multiple versions of media into Switch to compare it frame by frame if necessary.

LoudnessVUMeters

FIX IT

  • To round out the “Fix It’s” for Switch Pro, you have the ability to create  iTunes package presets including media content, secondary subtitle or audio files, chapter information and an XML file.

Something else that I want to point out, is that one feature I use in QuickTime, all the time, is the Inspector.  It’s my “go to” inspector, when I’m too lazy to go to MediaInfo.  It’s simple, straight to the point, and small so that I can take a screenshot of it, and easily send it to a client, or other editor if I need to.  Well, Switch has an inspector as well, and to be honest, I like it more than its QuickTime counterpart.  Again, simple, straightforward, in a small enough window to make it a simple snapshot and send, but with much more info in it like Color Space, Field Dominance and even Aspect Ratio, which are all simple, but important information that you need to know, at the click of a mouse.  

Inspector

SUPPORT

I want to mention, before I wrap up this article, that when you purchase Switch, you get one year of premium support, that gets you phone and priority e-mail support between 8-5pm PT, Remote Access Services, and most importantly Switch updates for a year.  

If I had to have one beef with Switch it’s that theDNxHD, JPEG2000, HEVC, DNxHR and AC3 playback should be included in the “Plus” version of switch, as it makes it a “complete” player by having those codecs unwatermarked with all the rest.  I’m a little surprised that they didn’t go this route, as it still puts money in their pockets, and keeps the big features like Loudness monitoring for the Pro version.  Telestream SHOULD include this feature as part of the “Plus” version for Switch 4, and it’s something I’m going to make sure they hear me on.

With the death of QuickTime, Telestream’s Switch is poised to rise from the ashes and take QuickTime’s place as your main application for all your file quality control, and viewing needs.  If you do any type of work that requires you to be monitoring things like audio levels, loudness, or need to compare before and after files, definitely consider Switch Pro.  It’s worth the $295 US.

For more information, or to download the free version of Telestream’s Switch, you can check it out on Telestream’s website.


Was This Post Helpful:

0 votes, 0 avg. rating

Kevin P. McAuliffe

Kevin P McAuliffe is a three time North American ProMax award winning editor and a Media Composer editor for over 15 years. He is a featured trainer at MacProVideo and is also one of the Senior Editor’s at MIJO in Toronto, Canada, with current clients including Paramount Pictures, Warner Bros. Pictures, Walt Disney Pictures and E1 Entertainment to name a few. He can also be found helping out on the Avid Community forums in the Media Composer & Symphony Get Started Fast forum.

Leave a Reply

Be the First to Comment!

Notify of
avatar
wpDiscuz