Production

FxFactory Pro and MOTYPE Review

Effects plugins for FCP, Motion, After Effects and Avid

image

Most people I know in this industry love new gear. And in the world of desktop video applications and editing, new gear is now less and less about the physical stuff with buttons and knobs and more about “the code.”

If you want access to a lot of new stuff, the easiest way to get high quality stuff to play with is to load FxFactory for Final Cut Pro, or FxFactory Pro with its 142 plug-ins already included. These plug-ins can be used in FCP, Motion, and After Effects. A similar product – Factory Tools – is available for Avid.

The very cool thing is that FxFactory is free and it gives you access to numerous free plug-ins. And I don’t mean “demo free” or “shareware free” or “for a limited time free.” I mean free. Now if you want to experience the true power of FxFactory, I won’t kid you, you are going to need to pony up some cash. FxFactory Pro gives you access to 142 plug-ins plus some other “pro” features for $399.

image

If you’re not ready to drop the $399 on FcFactory Pro, start out with the free download of FxFactory and experiment with the included plug-ins for the next two weeks. Do this when you have some time in your schedule to play and experiment a little. FxFactory Pro plug-ins load your FCP Effects>Video Filter menu with tons of yummy goodies. (Actually, FxFactory also creates generators and video transitions, which show up alongside the other generators and transitions inside FCP, instead of under Video Filters.) Play with them for a while and you’ll find that several of them become indispensable parts of your editing arsenal.

I just did a high profile project for the Chicago Cubs and FxFactory plug-ins made a big difference in the “sizzle factor” of the piece. Because the footage looked so special, a fellow producer I showed it to said “Who shot all of this footage?” I had to explain that it was just the same plain, vanilla footage that is broadcast during the games. “But it looks so cool,” she responded. That’s what a little FxFactory – and some color correction – will do for you.

Click here to view the FxFactory demo video.

The plug-ins that are provided with FxFactory show up in your Video Filters menu organized into several categories of effects: NI Blur, NI Color Correction, NI Distort, NI Generators, NI Glow, NI Halftones, NI Sharpen, NI Stylize, NI Tiling, NI Transitions and NI Video. Experience FCP effects users may look at that list and say “Well, half of that stuff is already in FCP already.” But the specific effects inside those categories seem to have been well chosen to dispel that argument. Though there are definitely Blur options in FCP, the ones in FxFactory are unique and I found myself turning more and more to the FxFactory versions of nearly every effect instead of the Apple factory versions. Plus, when you’re looking to make this project look different than your last project, it helps to have all of the options you can get. All effects packages have effects built in that you know you will never use. FxFactory is no exception, but I was impressed by the percentage of useful filters compared to the relatively minor amount of chaff. In the latest version (2.06) FxFactory now supplies thumbnail previews of the effects in FCP and After Effects.

The real story behind FxFactory isn’t really about the built-in plug-ins available from FxFactory Pro though. The interesting story is really that it is really a plug-in management system that allows you access to a wide variety of third-party plug-ins that can be demoed and purchased from Noise Industries’ elegant on-line store.


Once you’ve got FxFactory loaded on to your system, you can download a variety of effects that are all relatively inexpensive. Actually, as of this writing, there are six completely free plug-ins that can be downloaded and used. These aren’t demos but fully functional, permanent effects.

In addition to the freebies and the FxFactory Pro built-in effects, there are currently almost two dozen other plug-in effects packages that are available through FxFactory. Noise Industries has a very nice, clean, easy to use web-commerce site that makes trying and buying additional effects a pleasure. These include Titling, wipes, volumetric effects, automated numeric counters, color correction looks, Motion-style master templates, and background generators. Prices for these plug-ins range from $29 to $119. Each plug-in includes multiple effects. All of them come with trial versions so the best way to determine if it’s worth the money is to download it and put it through its paces before buying.

image

And beyond the stuff that you can buy, FxFactory Pro also unleashes the power to make your own custom plug-ins. This ability is limited to the Pro version. It’s not something that most users are likely to try themselves, but if you’ve got a cool idea for a plug-in you don’t actually have to write any code at all. FxFactory lets you tap in to Mac OS X’s Quartz Composer. It uses node-based compositing which allows you to do a number of pretty revolutionary things like combining parts of several FxFactory effects into a single plug-in or even changing the parameters of the plug-ins you have. You can create new plug-ins by pulling nodes from various Quartz Composer websites and building them into your own personalized effects. Heck if you get good enough at it, you can sell your plug-ins to other users on NI’s site and start your own personal stimulus package!


imageIf you’re like me though, you won’t be building your own effects anytime soon, so check out the plug-ins from the various vendors on NI’s site. One of the effects I tried was called Motype, Its marketing tag line promises “Easy Motion Title Design.” The rest of the pitch includes “Motype produces stunning text animations with an integrated motion mixer, character randomization, motion blur, letter particles, 3D camera and backgrounds.”

For me, this was a very difficult product to review. The results it achieved – turning simple one-word titles into sexy full screen motion graphics – were impressive, but it was also disappointing in its ability to actually do any real “titling.”

I also used MOTYPE for my Cubs project, though in the end all of the graphics that it churned out were eventually replaced with graphics from a designer, but it was nice to have really slick “place holders” that maintained the energy of the piece instead of cutting to “white-Helvetica-on-Black graphic-goes-here” titles.

Click here to view the MOTYPE demo video.

In trying to deliver a useful review, I suppose I should break down a few of the components of the product and you can determine which are important to you and which are not. Perhaps your expectations and needs are different from mine.

imageFirst off, the plug-in installs easily. Like most of you though, I don’t bother to read the read-me files or manuals so I was a little surprised that MOTYPE did not show up in my Effects menu like most of the other FxFactory plug-in. Instead, I accidentally found it several days after I installed it, added to the list of special clips and titling options in the Generator pop-up menu at the bottom right corner of the Viewer. Actually, several other titling and background-type FxFactory plug-ins end up in this menu instead of the main Effects menu, so if you can’t find a plug-in you downloaded, be sure to check there.

The plug-in was further buried in a submenu called Yanobox (the manufacturer’s company name). Once MOTYPE is launched, creating a title is done in the Controls tab with the familiar FCP controls that you’re used to with the basic Text generator. There are obviously some differences however.

imageThe easiest way to achieve quick, eye-popping results is to use the presets – what else is new? There are about two dozen presets. Some for HD some for SD. Checking out the presets is also the easiest way to see what the plug-in is capable of delivering. To add text go to the Text pulldown and specify your font, size, position, tracking, tracking animation, color, opacity, … oh yeah, and the actual text of your title. Beware though, MOTYPE is only capable of putting a single word or line of type on the screen. This was a huge disappointment. One line of text is a pretty killer limitation. The other thing that I was pretty unhappy with also showed up at this stage of the creation process: every time you change a preset style, the text reverts back to the factory default letters “YANOBOX MOTYPE” so it’s time-consuming and repetitive to see various presets using the text and style you actually want to employ for your final title. (I’ve since been told that in the next point release, custom text will be retained when presets are switched.)

The other controls allow you to create your own presets or edit the factory defaults. Some of the options you can play with include : variations of randomized character animations and how they come to rest into a finished title, motion mixing to determine where and how characters animate on screen, trailing blur, animated cameras, background and lighting, canvas start frame – and probably the most central aspect to creating cool looks – Particles, which includes a dizzying array of variables and options. So if you want to sit down and really make custom title effects that don’t look like the cookie-cutter drag and drop results that I see on so many LiveType knock-off graphics, you can really go to town and deliver results you’re unlikely to see elsewhere.


There is no doubt that MOTYPE can create some really cool looks, including the simple-to-use factory-default presets. It really depends on what kind of titles you need for your project. If you’re looking for more than a word or two of text, then this is not the plug-in for you. But if you’re trying to do big, flashy “promo-like” titles with one to three words in a single line, then this is for you. For my Cubs project, it was ideal because the fast-paced motion-intensive results that MOTYPE delivered were the perfect compliment to the fast-paced trailer-style editing of the rest of the piece.

Conclusions

imageTo conclude, I have to give a big “thumbs up” to FxFactory. It gives you easy access to a wealth of inexpensive plugins, including those in the FxFactory Pro package. The company’s site is well-designed and is filled with lots of good info and video tutorials.

imageAs for MOTYPE, it can do some great looking titles, but the current limitations mean that it’s of very limited value. Hopefully they’ll work the kinks out in future releases and you should keep an eye on it as it develops. As for the other plug-ins on the Noise Industry site, load them up when you have time to explore them and see which ones have a place in your repertoire. It’s good to see what’s available so that when a future project has a particular design challenge, you know if there’s a ready-made solution. Perhaps you can even include the purchase price of the plug-in you need under a “custom graphics” line item in your next budget!


Tags:

Share Our Article

Steve Hullfish has been producing and editing award-winning television since the mid-1980s. He has written six books, and edited four theatrical feature films (including two Number One New Movies in the US). He has lectured…

Leave a Reply

avatar
  Subscribe  
Notify of